← Main Menu  |  Book Contents  |  Introduction — Prelude  |  Chapter 1 →

The Rise and Fall of the NEW Four Seasons 1966 to 1977

Introduction — Prelude

Some people became fans of the Four Seasons the first time they heard them, others just grew into them. Being a hit group in 1962 they had nearly a decade of success and again in the 1970s they had another resurgence with a different line-up but the same lead singer Frankie Valli. Decades later new generations of fans would discover them as a result of the show 'Jersey Boys' or via Dance Mix Clubs and streaming services in the 21st Century. But what is it that changes your appreciation of an artist from merely collecting a few songs in a Spotify play list that you listen to, to wanting to know about all of their work and maybe collect it? They are today a long way from the early 60s hit makers of ‘Sherry’ fame….but they shared a link through Bob Gaudio and Frankie Valli, and those roots were a part of what we found connection with in the mid 1970s with a completely different sound thanks in the main to Gaudio and his search for finding the ‘current’ vibe.

I had for a few decades realised that there was really something more to the group than just Frankie Valli’s amazing voice but it was seeing the new line up in the mid 70s…... only to have them disappear …….that made me take a holistic view of Frankie Valli and all line ups in the catalogue up to 2010 that led to a fuller review of their work before and after those halcyon days of the 1970s. Well, between 2018 and 2023 I got the chance to review their whole catalogue, being co-compiler of the Snapper Music Box Set tracing their whole career of albums and rare and unreleased tracks. That culminated in the Box Set ‘Working Our Way Back To You’ – 44 CDs.- a vinyl insert and 2 books.

Chapter image 1

I had by 2009 already decided it was necessary to write about the past, because their music and its influence on our lives is something we don't really control. It is perhaps instinctive – a moment in time! However, I realised that understanding the music’s creation helps us know who we are and why we relate to it. I thought that this book might help put the music, the band and the fans in context with the times after the original line-up changed in 1965 and tell the story of how that change would cascade through the 60s and into the 70s to create the NEW Four Seasons. But also what happened since.

It is, to me, a case of understanding the music and the creators contributions in context via their own quotes and stories to show their place in the lives of fans in a better documented context. And one of my main intentions was that it might counter the myth of the show 'Jersey Boys' which is a commercial vehicle rather than a ‘musical and band biography’. The various group line-ups that happened during the 70s are not even mentioned in the Jersey Boys ‘stage show’ or movie. So I wanted to correct some aspects of their story which could otherwise remain hidden and in the future and maybe unknown. After all, seeing them for the first time during the 70s for fans like me made them ‘our-Four Seasons’

My discovery of the 'Chameleon' album and joining the UK fan club in 1976 was the catalyst for this research. But that owed much to the evolving role of the UK Appreciation Society and its cohorts which needed to be put in context with the Music. What I was to learn in the late 70s was that 'Chameleon' was just a part of a 'new' direction that Bob Gaudio had forced them to embark on from the Four Seasons back in 1965 when Nick Massi left the group. Writing and researching the Seasons story with George Ingram and other Four Seasons fans, as well as former members of the group over the years has enabled me to understand the context of the 'Chameleon' album in this process. And using the interviews with Bob and Frankie, the words of others involved in the music and the history of the groups recordings we can trace their driving creative ideas in response to the changing music scene. What became obvious was the contribution of the various producers, arrangers and other group members who have offered their stories and opinions during my research. There are peaks and troughs and not everyone behaves well. It is a story much like the one in Jersey Boys with the ups and downs of record companies, good and bad luck and trust and betrayal. But then isn't that what rock'n'roll has always been about?

But there is perhaps another over-riding reason for this attempt at a biography of sorts. In the book 'Jersey Boys' Rick Elice says that..,,,

"There are fictions in Jersey Boys that we created because the surviving members of the band did not want the real story to be told in a completely frontal way. There may have been certain relationships that they didn't want to re-kindle or agitate. And then there were issues that remain between Bob and Frankie, between Frankie and Tommy, between Tommy and the other two guys. Some things were out of bounds. We didn't necessarily know what these were until we wrote them and then were told, "No, you can't use that". Even so our original contract of intent with them was a warts-and-all version of their story. It would be a rags to riches story with specific landmarks from their lives and careers. There was a lot of concern between Bob and Frankie early on, before the play opened in La Jolla, that the fans would not tolerate some of the liberties that we were taking in terms of organisation and chronology of events. It was our contention that if the play were well made enough fans would buy into the show for it's own sake and not get hung up on the fact that we were taking dramatic license."

Well he was right on the first part that we bought into the show for the sake of theatre. After all the years since the 1970s with only occasional albums and tours we were just glad to find a way back to the music in a 'live' form. But I for one got hung up on the ‘dramatic licence’. I walked out of the theatre after a summer performance of ‘Jersey Boys’ in London hearing fans saying :- "Did you notice how they changed history in the second half of the show?".

Respected writer Charles Alexander recognises :- “

There is no hint of Valli's severe hearing loss that left him nearly deaf for many years until some operations helped ease the ailment. The most significant historical inaccuracy is that the play has Massi and DeVito leaving the group at about the same time when every fan knows that Nick left years before Tommy did. Fans may quarrel with this jumbled chronology, but they should understand that this is drama, not history."

And there lies the key. We all agree that the show is just a fantastic creation of the music and it’s back story - and none of this book is intended to counteract that. It is just that the real timeline needed to be told some time, someplace and so this is one attempt to set just part of the record straight based on what has been written and said in the fanzines and by some of the ‘players’. But ultimately it is focused on the music, its creation and the role of the Four Seasons group members. "Its always been about the group " said Valli in a July 2009 interview for the Boston Globe. The contribution each group member made during the period that represents the second half of the 'Jersey Boys' show should not be overlooked. They have, I believe, been given too little credit for the success that was achieved and the lack of credit of that group in the finale to Jersey Boys is hard for us fans to take.

Chapter image 2

"The Rise and Fall of the NEW Four Seasons" therefore attempts to document the musical and personnel development of the group from the time Bob Gaudio decided to take a classic Frank Sinatra standard and give it a whole new sound in 1965, to the abandonment of the most successful line-up in the groups history in 1977. (and the aftermath which cascaded through the 1980s, 90s and into the 21st Century) . What I am seeking to capture is showing that "The Four Seasons" has always been the ‘institution’ — one name covering multiple lineups and multiple lead singers in the 1970s and what this meant to fans — and Valli, while central and present in many of the songs, was one voice within that continuity rather than the entity itself. The UK fanbase's whole identity through the latter decades of the 20th century, and this book's title ( re-"The NEW Four Seasons"), is built on that same premise: the group ‘is’ the story, and its ability to reinvent itself with new members is part of what I am documenting, not incidental to it

It was back in 2009, an ambitious aim and in 2026 after the research for the Snapper Music Box Set I have been able to complete what I hope is an important music history book

The over-riding result of our research and writing does demonstrate the tremendous drive, talent and perseverance of Frankie Valli and Bob Gaudio. A belief in their creative talent and in Frankie's incredible voice over 5 decades. Examining this period leads me to judge this as their greatest achievement. Of all the groups from the 60s who had a resurgence in the 70s only the Four Tops in my opinion came close to matching the NEW Four Seasons in terms of staying ‘right for the time’….but the Tops did it with a constant line-up.

‘The Rise and Fall of The NEW Four Seasons’ traces the changes, influences and the creative direction of Bob Gaudio and the group until 'arguably' the eventual collapse of Bob's creative drive in 1977. At times at Motown and after 1980 the Four Seasons Partnership labelled the group as ‘Frankie Valli and the Four Seasons’ [right up to today] but to us in the 1970s that massive hit group labelled THE FOUR SEASONS became an identity the remains of the UK fan club wanted to ‘own’.

With the help of the fan base and former group members I have searched out the stories behind the ebbs and flows of their music, reflecting on their place in the changing music scene. And in doing so I have attempted to be honest but sensitive to the conflicts and issues. In writing this book I have aimed for what I believe is a balanced story with a fan's perspective.

One other thing that shines through this period ,and is reflected in the story, is the loyalty of the group's core fans who supported them and bought their records. Ultimately they would be let down and the fan clubs like the group would fall apart. The Four Seasons Partnership’s lack of rapport with the fans over the years may be because of their ‘shady' past and the need to protect the commercial appeal of the group. But maybe that did more harm than good. Jersey Boys commercial success would indicate the past didn't matter when the context of the music is pure! But this story is about respect and friendship. Between the fans and The Four Seasons with all of the personalities and their openness or not. A story only incomplete as a result of what Bob and Frankie themselves know and haven’t disclosed. As such it is not a biography but simply a fan’s perspective.

‘Casey Chameleon’

Chapter References/Credits:

Rick Elice: Charles Alexander: